Tuesday, January 29, 2013
What's the Problem? - Adam Shanabrook
After reading this article and listening to class discussions this week, I believe that team sports should not be divided until a certain age and skill level, while individual sports should allow any athlete who wants to play and has the skill to compete. I played many sports growing up, such as baseball, soccer, and basketball, and all of these sports were coed until we reached the age of 7 or 8. At this age, boys start to become more physical and girls tend to focus more on technique. This is where sport starts to change in aspect to gender because typically girls sports are more technical and focus on the skill of the game while boys sports typically are focused on the physicality of the sport. In middle school, every once in a while we would scrimmage the girls team in basketball and we were told to be physical. I remember one particular incident where we were playing the girls team and one of the boys had a hard foul on one of the girls and she ended up breaking her arm and ended her season. This shows how boys and girls team sports are different because the girls were not accustomed to the physical nature of the boys game, one of them got hurt. It is different though in individual sports, such as wrestling, golf, and tennis. I feel that as long as the athlete has the skill level to compete, they should be allowed to regardless of their gender. There have been many success stories about women competing with and beating men at these sports because of their skill level.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Adam,
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure if you were the one that brought up girls and boys can play together up to a certain age but I definitely like this idea. I like your examples about playing coed soccer as well. I have similar stories that our youth travel team would play the girls the same age and they were actually just as physical as we were and enjoyed playing against us. The differences in practices such as them learning more technical skill and we would learn more physical skills such as shielding the ball or running more was definitely evident. Unfortunately accidents do happen but the girls we play told us and the coaches that they liked competing against us because it made them better. Of course we never wanted to lose but they were our friends too and were making each other better by getting in extra scrimmages rather than ourselves. Depending on the sport this could happen often.
- Jeff Kravetz