Monday, January 28, 2013

Separation of Sports and Gender - Jeff Kravetz


Male and female athletes are not what they used be.  In sports today, we are seeing taller, faster and stronger athletes than ever before, both for male and female sports.  Within the last decade females such as Brittney Griner, Serena Williams and Alex Morgan have made great strides in the promotion and improvement of female sports.  Those types of athletes are changing the game in the public eye because the gap between skill levels is closing in.  Soccer for example, had Mia Hamm.  No other female in the United States and even the world had the recognition and skill to back up her abilities.  Now we are seeing handfuls and groups of players that could be as talented as Mia Hamm.

Males are looking like the same way.  Basketball is a sport that is always talking about comparing players to the NBA’s past time.  We are seeing many players today that are being compared to the likes of Jordan, Magic Johnson and Kareem both by talent and success. Whether LeBron or Kobe is the most similar to Jordan might never end. So how many basketball players today are being compared, being discussed by sports shows, to the NBA’s legends? Every day it seems like.  And to back it up, there have been so many athletes breaking decade-long records and it is happening not only in basketball.  All these current athletes still playing in their sports, LeBron, Kobe, Tiger Woods, Drew Brees, are becoming the youngest or own the most records than ever before.

The point I am trying to make is with the separation of males and females playing together would never work.  The big sports such as basketball, football, soccer and baseball would be the most difficult.  We are seeing more dominant female athletes, but at the same time we are seeing the most gifted male athletes as well.  It could possibly work with individual sports.  Tennis would be the most interesting since males and females are stronger and can serve and hit faster.  Billiards, bowling and maybe even golf would turn some heads to see how males and females would do competing against each other.

Bottom line: The way sports are separated now is fine.  More male and female athletes are leveling the playing field and some are still dominant, which is making sports even more exciting to watch.   

4 comments:

  1. Jeff,
    To begin I would like to say well put. I cannot disagree with the statement, "We are seeing more dominant female athletes, but at the same time we are seeing the most gifted male athletes as well. It could possibly work with individual sports" I feel the same. Times have changed but with this change we have seen a growth in sports. The biggest change in the fight for equality has been Title IX. I am proud that we are now in more equal settings but this does not mean we must remove the barriers of female and male sports. As dominating and athletic as females are, we cannot physically allow for someone to get hurt. In class we saw the sports science of a female boxer who hit harder than a male boxer. This was very impressive but at the same not very typical. We cannot expect Brittany Griner to be able to compete against LeBron James in a game of basketball. So physically, it would be unfair to integrate all sports and must be done on an individual basis.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Greg,
      I'm glad you agree on my thoughts about society seeing females and males being the most dominant than ever. The fact that Title IX has given more opportunities to women to compete has closed the gap between men and female separation in sports. When we discuss about the physical difference between males and females, women are definitely more physically built than in the past, which is good for the game in sports like the WNBA. Basketball would be interesting to watch because how would Brittney Griner compete and battle it out in the post with guys like Dwight Howard? He is an extreme case because he is a freak athlete but the proportion of male athletes like LeBron James who is 6'8 260 pounds could definitely cause injuries to females as well as males.

      Delete